5 Best Alternatives to Excel for Capital Planning

Data analytics dashboard

Excel is where most capital planning starts—and where many organizations get stuck. Spreadsheets work fine for small portfolios and simple programs, but they break down as scale and complexity grow. If you're experiencing version control issues, data quality problems, or reporting headaches, it's time to consider alternatives.

When Excel Stops Working

Spreadsheets serve capital planning well initially. They're flexible, familiar, and free (or close to it). But they hit limits:

Signs you've outgrown Excel:

Multiple people need to update the same data
You're managing more than 20-30 active projects
Version confusion causes decisions based on stale data
Reporting requires hours of manual work
Approval workflows exist only in email
Historical data is inconsistent or lost
Audit trail is incomplete or missing

What breaks:

Data integrity: Manual entry creates errors; no validation
Collaboration: Multiple versions with no single source of truth
Automation: Everything manual—reminders, notifications, approvals
Reporting: Building reports from scratch every time
Scalability: Performance degrades; complexity becomes unmanageable
Security: Limited access controls; easy to share inappropriately

If these problems sound familiar, evaluate alternatives.

5 Categories of Excel Alternatives

1. Purpose-Built CapEx Management Software

What it is: Software designed specifically for capital expenditure planning, approval, and tracking.

Examples: Banner, Honest Buildings, Procore (capital planning module), Kahua, Yardi CapEx

Best for: Organizations with significant capital programs seeking comprehensive functionality.

Key capabilities:

Capital budgeting and planning workflows
Project approval routing with configurable rules
Real-time budget vs. actual tracking
Portfolio-level dashboards and reporting
Document management for capital projects
Vendor and contractor management
Integration with accounting systems

Advantages:

Built for capital planning use cases
Workflow automation eliminates manual tasks
Purpose-built reporting and analytics
Strong audit trails and compliance support
Scales with portfolio growth

Considerations:

Higher cost than generic tools
Implementation requires configuration
May be overkill for simple needs
Evaluate carefully before selecting

When to choose: You have a dedicated capital program with ongoing projects across multiple properties and need comprehensive workflow automation.

2. Project Management Platforms

What it is: General project management software adapted for capital planning.

Examples: Monday.com, Asana, Smartsheet, Wrike, Airtable

Best for: Organizations wanting better collaboration and tracking without capital-specific features.

Key capabilities:

Project tracking with customizable fields
Task assignment and deadline management
Team collaboration and communication
Basic workflow automation
Dashboards and reporting
Document attachment and sharing

Advantages:

More affordable than specialized software
Flexible and customizable
Good collaboration features
Familiar interface for most users
Quick to implement

Considerations:

Requires significant configuration for capital planning
No built-in capital planning workflows
Limited integration with accounting systems
Reporting requires workarounds for capital metrics
May outgrow as needs become more sophisticated

When to choose: You need better project tracking and collaboration, have limited budget, and can invest time in configuration.

3. ERP Capital Planning Modules

What it is: Capital planning functionality within enterprise resource planning systems.

Examples: Oracle, SAP, Workday, NetSuite, Sage Intacct

Best for: Organizations already using ERP who want integrated capital planning.

Key capabilities:

Tight integration with financial systems
Unified chart of accounts and cost centers
Standard approval workflows
Consolidated reporting across operational and capital spending
Fixed asset management integration

Advantages:

Single source of truth with financials
No integration required—native functionality
Familiar interface for finance users
Strong compliance and audit capabilities
Leverages existing ERP investment

Considerations:

Often limited in project management functionality
May require expensive add-on modules
Configuration can be complex and costly
Less specialized for real estate/property needs
Updates tied to broader ERP upgrade cycles

When to choose: You're already on an ERP with capital planning modules and integration with financials is your top priority.

4. Construction Project Management Software

What it is: Software designed for construction project execution, with some capital planning features.

Examples: Procore, Autodesk Build, Buildertrend, CoConstruct, CMiC

Best for: Organizations primarily focused on construction execution who want upstream planning capability.

Key capabilities:

Project planning and scheduling
Bid management and contractor coordination
Field communication and documentation
Change order tracking
Budget and cost management
Quality and safety management

Advantages:

Strong construction execution features
Good for managing contractors and projects
Often includes mobile field apps
Purpose-built for construction workflows
Scales for large project volumes

Considerations:

Planning features secondary to execution
May be overkill if not managing construction directly
Often priced per project or seat
Less focused on portfolio-level capital planning
Integration with accounting may require work

When to choose: You're directly managing construction (not just owners oversight) and need robust execution tools.

5. Business Intelligence + Database Solutions

What it is: Custom solutions combining databases with visualization/reporting tools.

Examples: Power BI + SQL, Tableau + data warehouse, Google Sheets + Looker

Best for: Organizations with technical resources wanting maximum flexibility.

Key capabilities:

Complete customization of data model
Powerful visualization and reporting
Integration with any data source
Scalable to any data volume
Real-time dashboards

Advantages:

Maximum flexibility and customization
Can integrate disparate data sources
Powerful analytics and visualization
No subscription to specialized software
Scales with technical investment

Considerations:

Requires technical expertise to build and maintain
No built-in workflows or automation
Development and maintenance costs
Long implementation timeline
Risk of technical debt and key-person dependency

When to choose: You have strong technical resources, unique requirements not met by packaged solutions, and willingness to invest in custom development.

How to Choose the Right Alternative

Assess Your Requirements

Volume and complexity:

How many properties and projects?
How complex are your approval workflows?
How sophisticated are your reporting needs?

Integration needs:

What systems must the solution connect with?
How important is real-time financial integration?

User considerations:

How many people need access?
What's their technical sophistication?
Do they need mobile access?

Budget and resources:

What can you spend on software?
Do you have implementation resources?
Can you handle ongoing administration?

Match Solutions to Needs

Need	Best Fit
Comprehensive capital planning workflows	Purpose-built CapEx software
Better project tracking, limited budget	Project management platforms
Tight integration with existing ERP	ERP capital planning modules
Heavy construction management	Construction project management software
Maximum customization, technical resources	BI + database solutions

Evaluate Before Committing

Before selecting any alternative:

Define requirements specifically
See demos with your use cases
Talk to reference customers
Understand total cost of ownership
Assess implementation requirements
Test with a pilot if possible

Migration Considerations

Moving from Excel to any alternative requires planning:

Data migration:

What historical data needs to transfer?
How clean is your current data?
Who will validate migrated data?

Process changes:

What workflows will change?
Who needs training?
How will you manage the transition period?

Change management:

Who sponsors the change?
How will you drive adoption?
What's the timeline for full transition?

Avoiding common mistakes:

Don't underestimate data cleanup effort
Don't skip training
Don't try to migrate everything at once
Don't expect immediate productivity gains

Frequently Asked Questions

How much do these alternatives cost?

Ranges vary widely. Project management tools: $10-30/user/month. Purpose-built CapEx software: $500-5,000+/month depending on portfolio size. ERP modules: Often included but require configuration investment. Construction software: $300-1,000+/month per project. Custom solutions: Development costs vary widely.

Can I use multiple tools together?

Yes, many organizations use project management for task tracking alongside specialized software for capital planning and reporting. Ensure tools integrate or accept manual data transfer.

How long does implementation take?

Simple tools: Days to weeks. Purpose-built software: 2-4 months for basic implementation. ERP modules: 3-6+ months. Custom solutions: 6-12+ months. Plan for longer if data cleanup and process change are significant.

What should I do with existing Excel files?

Don't abandon them immediately. Use them as reference during transition. Migrate essential historical data to the new system. Archive for audit trail. Gradually phase out as new system proves reliable.